Published Document

Dental Treatment, Complaints and Regulatory Correspondence (2019–2026)

Documents displayed in this library have been explicitly marked as Published through the administrative workflow. Publication indicates intentional public availability. Publication does not certify legal status, evidential truth, or external validation.

Administrative Actions

This protected administrative action opens the existing authenticated workflow for creating a distinct canonical CDE record from this Published document.

Create canonical record from this document

Document Metadata

Title	Dental Treatment, Complaints and Regulatory Correspondence (2019–2026)
Description	Preserved correspondence concerning dental treatment, complaints, records access and subsequent escalation involving 3Dental Limerick, Old Quarter Dental, the Dental Council, Dental Complaints and other recipients. The archive contains communications dated 20 March 2019 to 19 June 2026. Allegations, responses, requests and institutional statements remain attributed to their respective sources. Inclusion does not establish the accuracy of any allegation, the adequacy of any response or the resolution of any dispute.
Institution / Source	3Dental Limerick; Old Quarter Dental; Dental Council; Dental Complaints; related correspondence
Category	Dental Healthcare — Complaints and Correspondence
Keywords	dental treatment · dental complaints · Dental Council · 3Dental Limerick · Old Quarter Dental · patient records · professional conduct · regulatory correspondence · records access
Publication Date	2026-10-26
Document Date	2026-06-19
Document Format	MBOX Mailbox Archive
Media Type	Mailbox
SHA-256	f5fd91f34024012a29cbe7daa1a9fa07c781e78447f9b9705e23aaed527e2aac
Document Identifier	DOC-2026-000711
Optional Reference Identifier	Not provided

Mailbox Overview

Parsed mailbox and message metadata reflects fields contained in the preserved MBOX archive. It does not independently establish mailbox completeness, sender identity, delivery, receipt, authorship, authenticity, factual accuracy, legal status, evidential sufficiency, or external validation. Contained messages remain projections of the preserved archive unless separately admitted through Document Intake.

Detected format	MBOX Mailbox Archive
Detected MBOX variant	mboxo
Message count	42
Parsed message count	42
Warning message count	15
Unparsed message count	0
Attachment total	45
Earliest message date recorded in archive	2019-03-20T08:48:10+00:00
Latest message date recorded in archive	2026-06-19T12:38:12+01:00
Message IDs present	42
Message IDs missing	0
Exact duplicate count	0
Original-file download availability	Original .mbox download available

Mailbox Message Index

Showing messages 1-25 of 42. Page 1 of 2. Public rendering is bounded to 25 message projections per page.

Index	Date	From	Subject	To	Attachment count	Parse status	Warning indicator
1	2026-06-19T12:38:12+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Complaint Concerning Treatment and Professional Conduct — 3Dental Limerick	info <info@dentalcouncil.ie>	1	parsed	No
2	2026-06-19T10:51:22+00:00	info <info@dentalcouncil.ie>	RE: Complaint Concerning Treatment and Professional Conduct — 3Dental Limerick	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	1	parsed	No
3	2026-06-08T13:31:23+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Complaint Concerning Treatment and Professional Conduct — 3Dental Limerick	info <info@dentalcouncil.ie>	5	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
4	2026-05-19T09:00:18+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Clarification of Position — 3Dental Limerick	limerick@3dental.ie, oldquarterdental@gmail.com, implants-limerick@3dental.ie	1	parsed	No
5	2026-05-05T15:21:30+01:00	mary@dentalcomplaints.ie	RE: Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	'Nick Moloney' <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	0	parsed	No
6	2026-05-05T15:15:12+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Clarification of Position — 3Dental Limerick	limerick@3dental.ie, oldquarterdental@gmail.com, implants-limerick@3dental.ie	1	parsed	No
7	2026-05-05T14:52:09+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	Mary <mary@dentalcomplaints.ie>	1	parsed	No
8	2026-05-05T14:30:44+01:00	mary@dentalcomplaints.ie	RE: Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	'Nick Moloney' <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	1	parsed	No
9	2025-10-17T16:11:13+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Formal Complaint — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	info <info@dentalcouncil.ie>	1	parsed	No
10	2025-10-17T14:29:56+00:00	info <info@dentalcouncil.ie>	RE: Formal Complaint — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	1	parsed	No
11	2025-09-22T15:13:42+01:00	mary@dentalcomplaints.ie	RE: Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick	'Nick Moloney' <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	0	parsed	No
12	2025-09-22T15:00:44+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick	mary@dentalcomplaints.ie	1	parsed	No
13	2025-09-22T14:57:25+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Formal Complaint — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	info@dentalcouncil.ie	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
14	2025-09-22T14:38:17+01:00	mary@dentalcomplaints.ie	RE: Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	'Nick Moloney' <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	1	parsed	No
15	2025-09-18T14:15:06+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Denial of Access — Encrypted Records \| Urgent remedy required (no mobile)	3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>, hello@3dental.ie, oldquarterdental@gmail.com, implants-limerick@3dental.ie, 3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>, dublin@3dental.ie, aungierst@3dental.ie, galway@3dental.ie	1	parsed	No
16	2025-09-19T17:37:12+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Urgent: Dental Harm, Denial of Remedy, and Escalation Under Protected Status ~ 3	micheal.martin@oireachtas.ie, simon.harris@oireachtas.ie, jim.ocallaghan@oireachtas.ie, Jennifer Carroll MacNeill <jennifer.carrollmacneill@oireachtas.ie>, Manus.Boyle@oireachtas.ie, Paraic.Brady@oireachtas.ie, Cathal.Byrne@oireachtas.ie, Joanne.Collins@oireachtas.ie, Alison.Comyn@oireachtas.ie, Joe.Conway@oireachtas.ie, Nessa.Cosgrove@oireachtas.ie, Teresa.Costello@oireachtas.ie, Shane.Curley@oireachtas.ie, Mark.Duffy@oireachtas.ie, Imelda.Goldsboro@oireachtas.ie, Laura.Harmon@oireachtas.ie, Garret.Kelleher@oireachtas.ie, Mike.Kennelly@oireachtas.ie, Eileen.Lynch@oireachtas.ie, Aubrey.Mccarthy@oireachtas.ie, Maria.McCormack@oireachtas.ie, Conor.Murphy@oireachtas.ie, PJ.Murphy@oireachtas.ie, Linda.Nelson-Murray@oireachtas.ie, Evanne.NiChuilinn@oireachtas.ie, Noel.ODonovan@oireachtas.ie, SarahJ.OReilly@oireachtas.ie, Dee.Ryan@oireachtas.ie, Nicole.Ryan@oireachtas.ie, Gareth.Scahill@oireachtas.ie, Patricia.Stephenson@oireachtas.ie, Garret.Ahearn@oireachtas.ie, Chris.Andrews@oireachtas.ie, frances.black@oireachtas.ie, Niall.Blaney@oireachtas.ie, victor.boyhan@oireachtas.ie, Nikki.Bradley@oireachtas.ie, maria.byrne@oireachtas.ie, pat.casey@oireachtas.ie, lorraine.cliffordlee@oireachtas.ie, Tom.Clonan@oireachtas.ie, martin.conway@oireachtas.ie, gerard.craughwell@oireachtas.ie, Ollie.Crowe@oireachtas.ie, mark.daly@oireachtas.ie, paul.daly@oireachtas.ie, aidan.davitt@oireachtas.ie, Mary.Fitzpatrick@oireachtas.ie, Joe.Flaherty@oireachtas.ie, Eileen.Flynn@oireachtas.ie, robbie.gallagher@oireachtas.ie, alicemary.higgins@oireachtas.ie, Sharon.Keogan@oireachtas.ie, sean.kyne@oireachtas.ie, michael.mcdowell@oireachtas.ie, ronan.mullen@oireachtas.ie, margaret.murphyomahony@oireachtas.ie, Malcolm.Noonan@oireachtas.ie, fiona.oloughlin@oireachtas.ie, joe.oreilly@oireachtas.ie, anne.rabbitte@oireachtas.ie, lynn.ruane@oireachtas.ie, Pauline.Tully@oireachtas.ie, diarmuid.wilson@oireachtas.ie	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
17	2025-09-19T17:36:18+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Urgent: Dental Harm, Denial of Remedy, and Escalation Under Protected Status ~ 2	micheal.martin@oireachtas.ie, simon.harris@oireachtas.ie, jim.ocallaghan@oireachtas.ie, Jennifer Carroll MacNeill <jennifer.carrollmacneill@oireachtas.ie>, michael.lowry@oireachtas.ie, padraig.maclochlainn@oireachtas.ie, david.maxwell@oireachtas.ie, paul.mcauliffe@oireachtas.ie, noel.mccarthy@oireachtas.ie, charlie.mcconalogue@oireachtas.ie, tony.mccormack@oireachtas.ie, marylou.mcdonald@oireachtas.ie, helen.mcentee@oireachtas.ie, donna.mcgettigan@oireachtas.ie, mattie.mcgrath@oireachtas.ie, seamus.mcgrath@oireachtas.ie, erin.mcgreehan@oireachtas.ie, conor.mcguinness@oireachtas.ie, john.mcguinness@oireachtas.ie, denise.mitchell@oireachtas.ie, kevinboxer.moran@oireachtas.ie, aindrias.moynihan@oireachtas.ie, michael.moynihan@oireachtas.ie, shane.moynihan@oireachtas.ie, jennifer.murnaneoconnor@oireachtas.ie, michael.murphy@oireachtas.ie, paul.murphy@oireachtas.ie, verona.murphy@oireachtas.ie, johnny.mythen@oireachtas.ie, gerald.nash@oireachtas.ie, Hildegarde Naughton <hildegarde.naughton@oireachtas.ie>, joe.neville@oireachtas.ie, natasha.newsomedrennan@oireachtas.ie, carol.nolan@oireachtas.ie, shonagh.niraghallaigh@oireachtas.ie, darragh.obrien@oireachtas.ie, cian.ocallaghan@oireachtas.ie, maeve.oconnell@oireachtas.ie, james.oconnor@oireachtas.ie, willie.odea@oireachtas.ie, kieran.odonnell@oireachtas.ie, richard.odonoghue@oireachtas.ie, robert.odonoghue@oireachtas.ie, Patrick O'Donovan <patrick.odonovan@oireachtas.ie>, ken.oflynn@oireachtas.ie, roderic.ogorman@oireachtas.ie, louis.ohara@oireachtas.ie, ryan.omeara@oireachtas.ie, louise.oreilly@oireachtas.ie, darren.orourke@oireachtas.ie, johnpaul.oshea@oireachtas.ie, christopher.osullivan@oireachtas.ie, padraig.osullivan@oireachtas.ie, liam.quaide@oireachtas.ie, maurice.quinlivan@oireachtas.ie, padraig.rice@oireachtas.ie, neale.richmond@oireachtas.ie, peter.roche@oireachtas.ie, eamon.scanlon@oireachtas.ie, conor.sheehan@oireachtas.ie, marie.sherlock@oireachtas.ie, brendan.smith@oireachtas.ie, duncan.smith@oireachtas.ie, niamh.smyth@oireachtas.ie, brian.stanley@oireachtas.ie, edward.timmins@oireachtas.ie, gillian.toole@oireachtas.ie, robert.troy@oireachtas.ie, peadar.toibin@oireachtas.ie, mark.wall@oireachtas.ie, barry.ward@oireachtas.ie, charles.ward@oireachtas.ie, mark.ward@oireachtas.ie, jennifer.whitmore@oireachtas.ie, eoin.obroin@oireachtas.ie, naoise.ocearuil@oireachtas.ie, sean.ofearghail@oireachtas.ie, donnchadh.olaoghaire@oireachtas.ie, naoise.omuiri@oireachtas.ie, ruairi.omurchu@oireachtas.ie, aengus.osnodaigh@oireachtas.ie, fionntan.osuilleabhain@oireachtas.ie	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
18	2025-09-19T17:35:26+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Urgent: Dental Harm, Denial of Remedy, and Escalation Under Protected Status ~ 1	micheal.martin@oireachtas.ie, simon.harris@oireachtas.ie, jim.ocallaghan@oireachtas.ie, Jennifer Carroll MacNeill <jennifer.carrollmacneill@oireachtas.ie>, ciaran.ahern@oireachtas.ie, william.aird@oireachtas.ie, catherine.ardagh@oireachtas.ie, ivana.bacik@oireachtas.ie, cathy.bennett@oireachtas.ie, grace.boland@oireachtas.ie, Richard Boyd Barrett <richard.boydbarrett@oireachtas.ie>, tom.brabazon@oireachtas.ie, John.brady@oireachtas.ie, brian.brennan@oireachtas.ie, shay.brennan@oireachtas.ie, colm.brophy@oireachtas.ie, James Browne <james.browne@oireachtas.ie>, pat.buckley@oireachtas.ie, colm.burke@oireachtas.ie, peter.burke@oireachtas.ie, mary.butler@oireachtas.ie, paula.butterly@oireachtas.ie, jerry.buttimer@oireachtas.ie, joanna.byrne@oireachtas.ie, malcolm.byrne@oireachtas.ie, thomas.byrne@oireachtas.ie, michael.cahill@oireachtas.ie, holly.cairns@oireachtas.ie, catherine.callaghan@oireachtas.ie, dara.calleary@oireachtas.ie, sean.canney@oireachtas.ie, micheal.carrigy@oireachtas.ie, matt.carthy@oireachtas.ie, jack.chambers@oireachtas.ie, sorca.clarke@oireachtas.ie, peterchap.cleere@oireachtas.ie, john.clendennen@oireachtas.ie, michael.collins@oireachtas.ie, niall.collins@oireachtas.ie, catherine.connolly@oireachtas.ie, john.connolly@oireachtas.ie, rose.conwaywalsh@oireachtas.ie, joe.cooney@oireachtas.ie, ruth.coppinger@oireachtas.ie, reada.cronin@oireachtas.ie, Cathal Crowe <cathal.crowe@oireachtas.ie>, sean.crowe@oireachtas.ie, david.cullinane@oireachtas.ie, jen.cummins@oireachtas.ie, john.cummins@oireachtas.ie, emer.currie@oireachtas.ie, martin.daly@oireachtas.ie, pa.daly@oireachtas.ie, aisling.dempsey@oireachtas.ie, maire.devine@oireachtas.ie, cormac.devlin@oireachtas.ie, alan.dillon@oireachtas.ie, pearse.doherty@oireachtas.ie, albert.dolan@oireachtas.ie, paul.donnelly@oireachtas.ie, paschal.donohoe@oireachtas.ie, timmy.dooley@oireachtas.ie, dessie.ellis@oireachtas.ie, mairead.farrell@oireachtas.ie, aidan.farrelly@oireachtas.ie, frank.feighan@oireachtas.ie, Michael Fitzmaurice <michael.fitzmaurice@oireachtas.ie>, sean.fleming@oireachtas.ie, norma.foley@oireachtas.ie, patthecope.gallagher@oireachtas.ie, gary.gannon@oireachtas.ie, james.geoghegan@oireachtas.ie, sinead.gibney@oireachtas.ie, paul.gogarty@oireachtas.ie, thomas.gould@oireachtas.ie, ann.graves@oireachtas.ie, noel.grealish@oireachtas.ie, johnny.guirke@oireachtas.ie, marian.harkin@oireachtas.ie, eoin.hayes@oireachtas.ie, seamus.healy@oireachtas.ie, danny.healyrae@oireachtas.ie, michael.healyrae@oireachtas.ie, rory.hearne@oireachtas.ie, barry.heneghan@oireachtas.ie, martin.heydon@oireachtas.ie, emer.higgins@oireachtas.ie, alan.kelly@oireachtas.ie, eoghan.kenny@oireachtas.ie, martin.kenny@oireachtas.ie, keira.keogh@oireachtas.ie, claire.kerrane@oireachtas.ie, john.lahart@oireachtas.ie, james.lawless@oireachtas.ie, paul.lawless@oireachtas.ie, george.lawlor@oireachtas.ie	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
19	2025-09-19T17:15:31+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Complaint Submission — 3Dental Limerick (Escalation under Protected Status)	mary@dentalcomplaints.ie	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
20	2025-09-19T16:19:05+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Ref: UR/IST/25/NON/72 — Request to Reconsider (Exhaustion of Remedies Evidenced)	OHCHR-Petitions <ohchr-petitions@un.org>	3	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
21	2025-09-18T16:02:36+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Rights-Based Escalation — Remedy Outstanding (Deadline: 20 September 2025, 17:00 IST)	oldquarterdental@gmail.com, 3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>, hello@3dental.ie, implants-limerick@3dental.ie, dublin@3dental.ie, aungierst@3dental.ie, galway@3dental.ie	2	parsed	No
22	2025-09-18T15:19:01+01:00	3 Dental at Old Quarter House <oldquarterdental@gmail.com>	Password as requested	Nick Moloney <Nickdebrief@gmail.com>	0	parsed	No
23	2025-09-18T15:08:26+01:00	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	Re: Denial of Access — Encrypted Records \| Remedy Required	3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>, hello@3dental.ie, oldquarterdental@gmail.com, implants-limerick@3dental.ie, dublin@3dental.ie, aungierst@3dental.ie, galway@3dental.ie	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
24	2025-09-18T14:52:36+01:00	3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>	Fwd: Response to complaint	nickdebrief@gmail.com	1	parsed_with_warnings	Yes
25	2025-09-18T11:46:49+01:00	3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>	Re: Denial of Access – Encrypted Records	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>	0	parsed	No

Parser warnings: No mailbox-level parser warnings were recorded.

Cases

Case relationships are represented in the Relationship Graph when case references are present in the mailbox projection.

Timeline

Chronological access remains available through the Mailbox Message Index and message dates recorded in the preserved archive.

CDE Platform Stage 38C — Live Relationship Inspector Binding

The graph is generated deterministically from published mailbox projections. CDE Platform Stage 38C binds graph-node selection to live Relationship Inspector content through one selection pathway; it does not change relationship extraction or the graph API.

Relationship Graph Theme Standard High Contrast

Relationship Graph loading.

Person Institution Email Case Reference Attachment Intake Record

Message Detail

Mailbox message index	25
Message size	20411
Contained-message digest	9c0e937fe1ad2c41d67e40b3c75937d06879b150544b8396630c1f40aacdba41
Source byte range	170812084–170832495
Preview mode	in_memory
Preview truncated	No
Subject	Re: Denial of Access – Encrypted Records
From	3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>
Sender	—
Reply-To	—
To	Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>
CC	—
Individual message date recorded in source	2025-09-18T11:46:49+01:00
Message-ID	<CAKJOAnz=xYUcOO2mwDhdMAskCDMHXGjrxdsRU=nrksy4vEbqRA@mail.gmail.com>
In-Reply-To	<04197CC5-0BCA-4273-ABCF-B4177BD9D276@gmail.com>
References	<6689224B-6AE1-4BA4-A027-DF59ABD86B8C@gmail.com> · <04197CC5-0BCA-4273-ABCF-B4177BD9D276@gmail.com>
MIME type	multipart/alternative
Attachment count	0
Parser warnings	No parser warnings were recorded.

Message Body

Good Morning Nick, Thank you for your email. Can we please kindly ask you if you have got another mobile number which is eligible for receiving SMS messages? If yes, can you please provide us with it so we can send a password for your records. Otherwise, can you please confirm your home address so we can send a registered letter to you with a password inside? If both options aren't suitable for you, can you please advise which method is the best for you to receive the password for your records? Thank you, Caroline Price Manager Kind Regards, 3Dental at Old Quarter House T: 061 414673 W: www.limerick@3dental.ie <http://www.oldquarterdental.ie/> On Thu, Sep 18, 2025 at 7:33 AM Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com> wrote: > Dear 3Dental Management & Data Protection Officer, > > Please find attached a rights-based escalation and GDPR notice relating > to: > > - > > Denial of access to personal records, contrary to GDPR Articles 12–15. > > This escalation is formally issued under my protected status as a Human > Rights Defender (UN Declaration, 1998). It is logged in the public > oversight archive and will be escalated further to the Data Protection > Commission and international digital rights bodies if remedy is not > provided. > > Required by: 20 September 2025 (17:00 IST). > > Failure to respond substantively will constitute documented obstruction > and will be published accordingly. > > 🔗 Oversight Archive: https://tinyurl.com/yhcm88yt > > 🔗 Protected Status (UN HRD): https://tinyurl.com/543d9ct > > Sincerely, > > > Nick Moloney > > > Attachment: Rights-Based Escalation & GDPR Notice — Records Access, > Invalid Address & Automated Letters.pdf > > > > > Begin forwarded message: > > *From: *Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com> > *Subject: **Denial of Access – Encrypted Records* > *Date: *17 September 2025 at 11:13:59 IST > *To: *3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie> > > Dear Ms. Price, > > Thank you for your reply and for providing the documents. > > However, I must note that I do not have a phone capable of receiving SMS > messages. As a result, the method you have chosen effectively prevents me > from accessing my own clinical and financial records. > > This constitutes a constructive denial of access. Under GDPR, the right of > access must be provided in a form accessible to the data subject. I > therefore request that you provide the password through an alternative > secure method (e.g. encrypted email, postal delivery, or another agreed > format). > > Unless resolved, I will be forced to treat this as a rights-based > obstruction and escalate accordingly. > > Kind regards, > > > Nick Moloney > > On 17 Sep 2025, at 09:46, 3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie> wrote: > > Dear Nick, > > Many thanks for your email and highlighting your concerns to management. > We take all complaints very seriously and will assure you this will be > investigated. > > Please find attached a full copy of your records. Please note these are > password protected and you will receive an SMS with the password in order > for you to access this information. > > I would just like to point out that Magda was on annual leave when you > sent her an email. If you have a look at the email address in Magda's > automated vacation responder, it was provided as > aisling-limerick@3dental.ie. However, the email address that you received > a bounce back from is ailsing-limerick@3dental.ie. It seems that may have > been a typo when you were composing the email to Aisling, which is > completely an understandable human error. > > You have not attended the clinic since February 2020, so I am unsure what > you are referring to. Our dentists will always advise the best course of > action for your oral health. It is entirely the patients decision if they > proceed with treatment. > > The letter you received from Dr Rinon is just a standardised letter we > send out to patients, to make them aware of outstanding balances they have > on their account. You have an

Sanitised HTML preview

Good Morning Nick,

Thank you for your email.

Can we please kindly ask you if you have got another mobile number which is eligible for receiving SMS messages? If yes, can you please provide us with it so we can send a password for your records.

Otherwise, can you please confirm your home address so we can send a registered letter to you with a password inside?

If both options aren't suitable for you, can you please advise which method is the best for you to receive the password for your records?

Thank you,

Caroline Price

Manager

Kind Regards,

3Dental at Old Quarter House

T: 061 414673

W: www.limerick@3dental.ie

On Thu, Sep 18, 2025 at 7:33 AM Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear 3Dental Management & Data Protection Officer,
Please find attached a rights-based escalation and GDPR notice relating to:
Denial of access to personal records, contrary to GDPR Articles 12–15.
This escalation is formally issued under my protected status as a Human Rights Defender (UN Declaration, 1998). It is logged in the public oversight archive and will be escalated further to the Data Protection Commission and international digital rights bodies if remedy is not provided.
Required by: 20 September 2025 (17:00 IST).
Failure to respond substantively will constitute documented obstruction and will be published accordingly.
🔗 Oversight Archive: https://tinyurl.com/yhcm88yt
🔗 Protected Status (UN HRD): https://tinyurl.com/543d9ct
Sincerely,

Nick Moloney

Attachment: Rights-Based Escalation & GDPR Notice — Records Access, Invalid Address & Automated Letters.pdf

Begin forwarded message:

From: Nick Moloney <nickdebrief@gmail.com>
Subject: Denial of Access – Encrypted Records
Date: 17 September 2025 at 11:13:59 IST
To: 3Dental Limerick <limerick@3dental.ie>

Dear Ms. Price,
Thank you for your reply and for providing the documents.
However, I must note that I do not have a phone capable of receiving SMS messages. As a result, the method you have chosen effectively prevents me from accessing my own clinical and financial records.
This constitutes a constructive denial of access. Under GDPR, the right of access must be provided in a form accessible to the data subject. I therefore request that you provide the password through an alternative secure method (e.g. encrypted email, postal delivery, or another agreed format).
Unless resolved, I will be forced to treat this as a rights-based obstruction and escalate accordingly.
Kind regards,

Attachments

Attachments remain components of the preserved MBOX archive unless separately admitted through Document Intake.

Filename	Media type	Byte size	Disposition	Content ID	Attached message
No attachment metadata was detected for this contained message.

Mailbox Governance Boundary

Download original .mbox

Publication Provenance

Publication provenance records the administrative pathway by which this document became publicly available through CDE. It does not certify the document’s legal status, evidential truth, authorship, or external validation.

Intake date and time: 2026-10-26T14:07:00.016305Z
Intake mode: Governed Streaming Mailbox Intake
Streaming upload started: 2026-10-26T14:06:54.384473Z
Streaming upload completed: 2026-10-26T14:06:58.590364Z
Streaming validation completed: 2026-10-26T14:06:59.848788Z
Streaming finalisation timestamp: 2026-10-26T14:07:00.016305Z
Configured streaming limit: 1073741824 bytes
Document date: 2026-06-19
Server-detected document format: MBOX Mailbox Archive
Detected MBOX variant: mboxo
MBOX message count: 42
Outlook archive type: —
Outlook parser status: —
Outlook parser version: —
Outlook preservation complete: —
Outlook hash verification status: —
Outlook inspection complete: —
Outlook inspection timestamp: —
Outlook projection state: —
Outlook archive job identifier: —
Archive source: —
Gmail Takeout parser version: —
Gmail Takeout preservation complete: —
Gmail Takeout projection state: —
Archive source: —
IMAP acquisition timestamp: —
IMAP acquisition hash: —
IMAP preservation complete: —
IMAP projection state: —
Original filename: mbox.mbox
File size: 257961315 bytes
SHA-256 digest: f5fd91f34024012a29cbe7daa1a9fa07c781e78447f9b9705e23aaed527e2aac
SHA-512 digest: —
Document Identifier: DOC-2026-000711
Current lifecycle: Original lifecycle
Initial intake actor: nick
Review actor: nick
Approval actor: nick
Publication actor: nick
Review timestamp: —
Approval timestamp: —
Publication timestamp: 2026-10-26T14:08:50.462860Z
Current lifecycle state: Published
Optional Reference Identifier: —
Public presentation mode: Mailbox archive metadata, paginated message inspection, safe body previews, and original-file download
Original-file download availability: Original .mbox download available

The SHA-256 digest identifies the exact original bytes admitted through Document Intake. It supports byte-level comparison of the preserved file but does not independently establish authorship, factual accuracy, legal status, or external authenticity.

Publication Pathway

Original lifecycle

Timestamp	Previous status	New status	Actor	Note
2026-10-26T14:07:00.016305Z	Initial state	Pending Intake	nick	Document uploaded to pending intake through Governed Streaming Mailbox Intake.
2026-10-26T14:08:05.596757Z	Pending Intake	Under Review	nick	Review initiated for the preserved dental correspondence MBOX. Assessment covers source integrity, provenance, correspondence scope, chronology, attribution, attachments and relevant limitations. The original source remains unchanged.
2026-10-26T14:08:26.871550Z	Under Review	Approved	nick	Review completed and approved within the recorded scope and limitations. Approval concerns the evidential treatment of the preserved source and does not establish the truth of allegations, endorse institutional responses or authorize unrestricted publication of attachments or sensitive information.
2026-10-26T14:08:50.462860Z	Approved	Published	nick	Publication declared for the approved representation of the preserved MBOX, subject to its recorded provenance, qualifications, limitations, privacy review and exclusions. Correspondence, allegations and institutional statements remain attributed to their respective sources. Publication does not determine the merits of any complaint or authorize separate publication of attachments or sensitive personal information.

Actor identifies the administrative identity recorded for the lifecycle action. It does not by itself establish authorship, factual verification, or legal responsibility for the document contents.